shorewall_code/Shorewall/releasenotes.txt

Shorewall 3.4.2

Release Highlights

1)  Shorewall can now be tailored to reduce its footprint on embedded
    systems. As part of this change, actions are now completely
    optional.

    See http://www.shorewall.net/Modularization.html for details.

2)  Exclusion is now possible in /etc/shorewall/hosts. This is required
    for bridge/firewalls under kernel 2.6.20 and later.

    See http://www.shorewall.net/NewBridge.html.

3)  Shorewall and Shorewall Lite now include man pages. There is a 
    man page for shorewall(8), one for shorewall-lite(8) and one for
    each configuration file. As part of this change, all documentation
    has been removed from Shorewall configuration files. This should
    make it easier from users to upgrade from one release to the next
    since the configuration files will only change when column is added
    or renamed.

    See http://www.shorewall.net/manpages/Manpages.html

4)  Shorewall now remembers the changes that it has made to routing as
    a result of entries in /etc/shorewall/providers and
    /etc/shorewall/route_rules and reverses those changes when
    appropriate.

Problems corrected in Shorewall 3.4.2

1)  The /usr/share/shorewall[-lite]/modules file has been updated for
    kernel 2.6.20.

Migration Considerations:

If you are migrating from a Shorewall version earlier than 3.2.0 then
please see the 3.2.9 release notes for additional migration
information.

http://www.shorewall.net/pub/shorewall/3.2/shorewall-3.2.9/releasenotes.txt

1)  Shorewall supports the notion of "default actions". A default
    action defines a set of rules that are applied before a policy is
    enforced. Default actions accomplish two goals:

    a) Relieve log congestion. Default actions typically include rules
       to silently drop or reject traffic that would otherwise be logged
       when the policy is enforced.

    b) Insure correct operation. Default actions can also avoid common
       pitfalls like dropping connection requests on TCP port 113. If
       these connections are dropped (rather than rejected) then you
       may encounter problems connecting to internet services that
       utilize the AUTH protocol of client authentication.

    In prior Shorewall versions, default actions (action.Drop and
    action.Reject) were defined for DROP and REJECT policies in
    /usr/share/shorewall/actions.std. These could be overridden in
    /etc/shorewall/actions.

    This approach has two drawbacks:

    a) All DROP policies must use the same default action and all
       REJECT policies must use the same default action.

    b) Now that we have modularized action processing (see the New
       Features section below), we need a way to define default rules
       for a policy that does not involve actions.

    If you have not overridden the defaults using entries in
    /etc/shorewall/actions then you need make no changes to migrate to
    Shorewall version 3.4. Otherwise, please see item 3) in the New
    Features below.

2)  The 'Limit' action is now a builtin. If you have 'Limit' listed in
    /etc/shorewall/actions, remove the entry. Also remove the files
    /etc/shorewall/action.Limit and/or /etc/shorewall/Limit if you have
    them.

3)  This issue only applies if you have entries in
    /etc/shorewall/providers.

    Previously, Shorewall has not attempted to undo the changes it has
    made to the firewall's routing as a result of entries in
    /etc/shorewall/providers and /etc/shorewall/routes. Beginning with
    this release, Shorewall will attempt to undo these changes.

    See item 15 under new features below for additional information.

    This change can present a migration issue in that the 
    initial routing configuration when this version of Shorewall is
    installed has probably been changed by Shorewall already. Hence,
    when Shorewall restores the original configuration, it will be
    installing a configuration that the previously-installed version
    has already modified.

    The steps to correcting this after you have installed this version
    of Shorewall are as follows:

    a) "shorewall[-lite] stop"
    b) Be sure that the files /var/lib/shorewall[-lite]/default_route
       and /var/lib/shorewall[-lite]/undo_routing do not exist. If they
       do exist, remove them.
    b) Either restart networking or reboot.

4)  This issue only applies if you run Shorewall Lite. 

    The /etc/shorewall-lite/shorewall.conf file has been renamed
    /etc/shorewall-lite/shorewall-lite.conf. When you upgrade,
    your shorewall.conf file will be renamed shorewall-lite.conf.

New Features in Shorewall 3.4:

1)  In order to accomodate small embedded applications, Shorewall 3.4
    is now modularized. In addition to the base files, there are
    loadable "libraries" that may be included or omitted from an
    embedded system as required.

    Loadable Shorewall libraries reside in /usr/share/shorewall/ and
    have names that begin with "lib.". The following libraries are
    included in Shorewall 3.4:

    - lib.accounting. Must be available if you include entries in
      /etc/shorewall/accounting.

    - lib.actions. Must be available if you do not specify
      USE_ACTIONS=No in /etc/shorewall/shorewall.conf.

    - lib.base. The base Shorewall library required by all programs,
      including compiled firewall scripts. This library is also
      released as part of Shorewall Lite and is installed in
      /usr/share/shorewall-lite/.

    - lib.cli. Library containing the code common to /sbin/shorewall,
      /sbin/shorewall-lite. This library is also released as part of
      Shorewall Lite and is installed in /usr/share/shorewall-lite/.

    - lib.config. Library containing the code that is common to
      /usr/share/shorewall/compiler and /usr/share/shorewall/firewall. 

    - lib.dynamiczones. Must be available if you specify
      DYNAMIC_ZONES=Yes in shorewall.conf.

    - lib.maclist. Must be available if you specify the 'maclist'
      option in /etc/shorewall/interfaces or /etc/shorewall/hosts.

    - lib.nat. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/masq, /etc/shorewall/nat or /etc/shorewall/netmap
      or if you use DNAT or REDIRECT rules.

    - lib.providers. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/providers.

    - lib.proxyarp. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/proxyarp or if you specify the 'proxyarp' option
      in /etc/shorewall/interfaces.

    - lib.tc. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/tcdevices and /etc/shorewall/tcclasses.

    - lib.tcrules. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/tcrules.

    - lib.tunnels. Must be available if you have entries in
      /etc/shorewall/tunnels.

    Embedded applications can further decrease the size of the Shorewall
    footprint by:

    - Omitting the macro files.
    - Omitting all unused extension scripts.

    See http://www.shorewall.net/Modularization.html for additional
    details.

2)  As hinted in the previous bullet, there is a new USE_ACTIONS option
    in /etc/shorewall/shorewall.conf. Shorewall actions can be very
    powerful but they also require a lot of code to implement. Embedded
    applications can omit that code by setting
    USE_ACTIONS=No. Shorewall will ignore all action-related files
    including /usr/share/shorewall/actions.std and
    /etc/shorewall/actions. Builtin actions will still be available for
    use in rules and macros.

    The 'Limit' action has been converted to a builtin so that Limit is
    available even when USE_ACTIONS=No.

    See the next item for more information.

3)  Prior to Shorewall 3.4, default actions were specified in
    /usr/share/shorewall/actions.std or in /etc/shorewall/actions.

    This approach has two drawbacks:

    a) All DROP policies must use the same default action and all
       REJECT policies must use the same default action.

    b) Now that we have modularized action processing (see the New
       Features section below), we need a way to define default rules
       for a policy that does not involve actions.

    The solution is two-fold:

    - Four new options have been added to the
      /etc/shorewall/shorewall.conf file that allow specifying the
       default action for DROP, REJECT, ACCEPT and QUEUE.

       The options are DROP_DEFAULT, REJECT_DEFAULT, ACCEPT_DEFAULT and
       QUEUE_DEFAULT.

       DROP_DEFAULT describes the rules to be applied before a
       connection request is dropped by a DROP policy; REJECT_DEFAULT
       describes the rules to be applied if a connection request is
       rejected by a REJECT policy. The other two are similar for
       ACCEPT and QUEUE policies.

       The value assigned to these may be:

       	a) The name of an action.
	b) The name of a macro
	c) 'None' or 'none'

       The default values are:

	DROP_DEFAULT="Drop"
	REJECT_DEFAULT="Reject"
	ACCEPT_DEFAULT=none
	QUEUE_DEFAULT=none

       If USE_ACTIONS=Yes, then these values refer to action.Drop and
       action.Reject respectively. If USE_ACTIONS=No, then these values
       refer to macro.Drop and macro.Reject.

       If you set the value of either option to "None" then no default
       action will be used and the default action or macro (if any)
       must be specified in /etc/shorewall/policy

    - The POLICY column in /etc/shorewall/policy has been extended.

       In /etc/shorewall/policy, when the POLICY is DROP, REJECT,
       ACCEPT or QUEUE then the policy may be followed by ":" and one
       of the following:

	a) The word "None" or "none". This causes any default
	   action defined in /etc/shorewall/shorewall.conf
	   to be omitted for this policy.
	b) The name of an action (requires that USE_ACTIONS=Yes
	   in shorewall.conf). That action will be invoked
	   before the policy is enforced.
	c) The name of a macro. The rules in that macro will
	   be applied before the policy is enforced. This
	   does not require USE_ACTIONS=Yes.

    Example:

	#SOURCE		DEST		POLICY		LOG
	#						LEVEL
	loc		net		ACCEPT
	net		all		DROP:MyDrop	info
	#
	# THE FOLLOWING POLICY MUST BE LAST
	#
	all		all		REJECT:MyReject	info

4)  For users whose kernel and iptables have Extended MARK Target
    support, it is now possible to logically AND or OR a value into the
    current packet mark by preceding the mark value (and optional mask)
    with an ampersand ("&") or vertical bar ("|") respectively.

    Example: To logically OR the value 4 into the mark value for
    packets from 192.168.1.1:

    #MARK   SOURCE
    |4	    192.168.1.1

5)  Previously, zone names were restricted to five characters in
    length. That limit derives from the --log-prefix in Netfilter log
    messages which must be 29 bytes or less in length. With the
    standard Shorewall LOGFORMAT, that leaves 11 characters for the
    chain name; given that many chain names are of the form
    <zone1>2<zone2>, that gives a maximum zone name length of 5.

    Beginning with this release, the maximum length of a zone name is
    dependent on the LOGFORMAT (the maximum length may never be less
    than 5 but it may be greater than 5). For example, setting
    LOGFORMAT="FW:%s:%s:" will allow zone names of up to 8 characters.

6)  Netfilter provides support for attachment of comments to Netfilter
    rules. Comments can be up to 255 bytes in length and are visible
    using the "shorewall show <chain>", "shorewall show nat",
    "shorewall show mangle" and "shorewall dump" commands. Comments are
    delimited by '/* ... */" in the output.

    Beginning with Shorewall 3.4, you may place COMMENT lines in the
    /etc/shorewall/rules, /etc/shorewall/tcrules, /etc/shorewall/nat
    and /etc/shorewall/masq files and in action files. The remainder of
    the line is treated as a comment and it will be attached as a
    Netfilter comment to the rule(s) generated by succeding entries
    in the file.

    Note: Do not prefix the comment with "#". Shorewall's two-pass
    compiler strips off "#" comments in the first pass and processes
    COMMENT lines in the second pass. Hence, by the time that COMMENT
    is processed, the "#" and everything following it has been removed
    (see example below).

    To stop the current comment from being attached to further
    rules, simply include COMMENT on a line by itself (so that the
    following rules will have no comment) or specify a new COMMENT.

    If you do not have Comment support in your iptables/kernel (see the
    output of "shorewall[-lite] show capabilities") then COMMENTS are
    ignored with this warning:

     COMMENT ignored --  requires comment support in iptables/Netfilter

    Example from my rules file:

	    #SOURCE      SOURCE     DEST       PROTO DEST PORT(S)

	    COMMENT Stop Microsoft Noise

	    REJECT       loc        net        tcp   137,445
	    REJECT       loc        net        udp   137:139

	    COMMENT  # Stop comment from being attached to rules below

    The output of "shorewall show loc2net" includes (folded):

    0     0 reject     tcp  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0
	  0.0.0.0/0    multiport dports 137,445 /* Stop Microsoft Noise */
    0     0 reject     udp  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0
	  0.0.0.0/0    udp dpts:137:139 /* Stop Microsoft Noise */

7)  A new macro (macro.RDP) has been added for Microsoft Remote
    Desktop. This macro was contributed by Tuomo Soini.

8)  A new 'maclog' extension file has been added. This file is
    processed just before logging based on the setting of
    MACLIST_LOG_LEVEL is done. When the extension is invoked, the CHAIN
    variable will contain the name of the chain where rules should be
    inserted. Remember that if you have specified MACLIST_TABLE=mangle,
    then your run_iptables commands should include "-t mangle".

9)  The SUBNET column in /etc/shorewall/masq has been renamed SOURCE to
    more accurately describe the contents of the column.

10) Previously, it was not possible to use exclusion in
    /etc/shorewall/hosts. Beginning with this release, you may now use
    exclusion lists in entries in this file. Exclusion lists are
    discussed at:

       http://www.shorewall.net/configuration_file_basics.htm#Exclusion.

    Example:

	loc	eth0:192.168.1.0/24!192.168.1.4,192.168.1.16/28

    In that example, the 'loc' zone is defined to be the subnet
    192.168.1.0/24 interfacing via eth0 *except* for host 192.168.1.4
    and hosts in the sub-network 192.168.1.16/28.

11) New "shorewall[-lite] show ip" and "shorewall[-lite] show routing"
    commands have been added. The first produces the same output as "ip
    addr ls". The second produces a report about your routing rules and
    tables.

12) Beginning with this release, Shorewall and Shorewall Lite will
    share common change logs and release notes.

13) In Shorewall versions prior to 3.4, multiple jumps to a '2all'
    chain could be generated in succession.

    Example from an earlier shorewall version:

    gateway:~ # shorewall-lite show eth2_fwd
    Shorewall Lite 3.4.0-Beta1 Chains eth2_fwd at gateway - Thu Oct 19 08:54:37 PDT 2006

    Counters reset Thu Oct 19 08:34:47 PDT 2006

    Chain eth2_fwd (1 references)
     pkts bytes target     prot opt in     out     source            destination
        0     0 dynamic    all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0           state INVALID,NEW
        0     0 wifi2all   all  --  *      eth0    0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0
        0     0 wifi2all   all  --  *      br0     0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0
        0     0 wifi2all   all  --  *      eth3    0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0
        0     0 wifi2all   all  --  *      tun+    0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0
    gateway:~ #

    This redundancy may be eliminated by setting OPTIMIZE=1 in shorewall.conf.

    gateway:~ # shorewall-lite show eth2_fwd
    Shorewall Lite 3.4.0-Beta1 Chains eth2_fwd at gateway - Thu Oct 19 09:15:24 PDT 2006

    Counters reset Thu Oct 19 09:15:19 PDT 2006

    Chain eth2_fwd (1 references)
     pkts bytes target     prot opt in     out     source               destination
        0     0 dynamic    all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0           state INVALID,NEW
        0     0 wifi2all   all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0
    gateway:~ #

    Note that with OPTIMIZE=1, traffic destined for an
    interface/Address that falls outside of all defined zones may now
    be logged out of a '2all' chain rather than out of the FORWARD
    chain.

    The OPTIMIZE setting also controls the suppression of redundant
    wildcard rules (those specifying "all" in the SOURCE or DEST
    column). A wildcard rule is considered to be redundant when it
    has the same ACTION and Log Level as the applicable policy.

    Example:

	/etc/shorewall/policy

	#SOURCE		DEST		POLICY		LEVEL
	loc		net		ACCEPT

        /etc/shorewall/rules

	#ACTION		SOURCE		DEST	PROTO	DEST
	#						PORT(S)
	...
	ACCEPT		all		all	icmp	8

    OPTIMIZE=0

    gateway:~ # shorewall show loc2net
    Shorewall Lite 3.4.0-Beta1 Chains loc2net at gateway - Thu Oct 26 07:55:03 PDT 2006

    Counters reset Thu Oct 26 07:54:58 PDT 2006

    Chain loc2net (1 references)
     pkts bytes target     prot opt in     out     source               destination
      ...
        0     0 DROP       all  --  *      *      !192.168.0.0/22       0.0.0.0/0
        0     0 ACCEPT     icmp --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0           icmp type 8
        0     0 ACCEPT     all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0

    gateway:~

    OPTIMIZE=1

    gateway:~ # shorewall show loc2net
    Shorewall Lite 3.4.0-Beta1 Chains loc2net at gateway - Thu Oct 26 07:57:12 PDT 2006

    Counters reset Thu Oct 26 07:56:38 PDT 2006

    Chain loc2net (1 references)
     pkts bytes target     prot opt in     out     source               destination
      ...
        0     0 DROP       all  --  *      *      !192.168.0.0/22       0.0.0.0/0
        0     0 ACCEPT     all  --  *      *       0.0.0.0/0            0.0.0.0/0

    gateway:~

    If you really want a rule that duplicates the policy, follow the
    action with "!":

	#ACTION		SOURCE		DEST	PROTO	DEST
	#						PORT(S)
	...
	ACCEPT!		all		all	icmp	8

14) IP Address ranges are now allowed in the drop, reject, allow and
    logdrop shorewall[-lite] commands.

15) Previously, Shorewall has not attempted to undo the changes it has
    made to the firewall's routing as a result of entries in
    /etc/shorewall/providers and /etc/shorewall/routes. Beginning with
    this release, Shorewall will attempt to undo these changes.

    When Shorewall starts or is restarted and there are entries in
    /etc/shorewall/providers, Shorewall will capture the contents
    of /etc/shorewall/rt_tables and will restore that database when
    Shorewall is stopped or restarted. Similarly, the default route
    will be captured the first time that you [re]start Shorewall using
    this version and will be restored under the following conditions:

    a) shorewall stop
    b) shorewall clear
    c) shorewall restart or restore and there are no entries in
       /etc/shorewall/providers.

    Once the default route has been restored, Shorewall will delete
    the saved copy so that it will once again be captured at the next
    shorewall start or shorewall restore.

16) Shorewall no longer includes policy matches in its generated
    ruleset when no IPSEC zones or IPSEC networks are defined (IPSEC
    networks are defined using the 'ipsec' option in
    /etc/shorewall/hosts).

17) The Makefile installed in /usr/share/shorewall/configfiles/ is now
    the same one mentioned at
    http://www.shorewall.net/CompiledPrograms.html.

    Once the file is copied into an export directory, you modify the
    setting of the HOST variable to match the name of the remote
    firewall.

    The default target is the "firewall" script so "make" compiles the
    firewall script if any of the configuration files have
    changed. "make install" builds "firewall" if necessary then
    installs it on the remote firewall. "make capabilities" will
    generate the "capabilities" file. "make save" will save the running
    configuration on the remote firewall.

18) Shorewall and Shorewall Lite now include the following manpages. 

	      shorewall-accounting(5)
	      shorewall-actions(5)
	      shorewall-blacklist(5)
	      shorewall.conf(5)
	      shorewall-ecn(5)
	      shorewall-exclusion(5)
	      shorewall-hosts(5)
	      shorewall-interfaces(5)
	      shorewall-lite.conf(5)
	      shorewall-lite(8)
	      shorewall-maclist(5)
	      shorewall-masq(5)
	      shorewall-nat(5)
	      shorewall-nesting(5)
	      shorewall-netmap(5)
	      shorewall-params(5)
	      shorewall-policy(5)
	      shorewall-providers(5)
	      shorewall-proxyarp(5)
	      shorewall-rfc1918(5)
	      shorewall-route_rules(5)
	      shorewall-routestopped(5)
	      shorewall-rules(5)
	      shorewall-tcclasses(5)
	      shorewall-tcdevices(5)
	      shorewall-tcrules(5)
	      shorewall-template(5)
	      shorewall-tos(5)
	      shorewall-tunnels(5)
	      shorewall(8)
	      shorewall-zones(5)

    Now that the manpages are in place, command-specific help has been
    removed since it duplicates information in the man pages.

19) From the beginning, the Shorewall configuration files in
    /etc/shorewall/ have contained documentary comments. While these
    comments are useful, they present an upgrade problem. Beginning
    with this release, these comments are removed from the
    configuration files themselves and are replaced by the manpages
    described in the preceding release note entry.

20) Shorewall now uses tc fwmark filters to classify packets for
    traffic shaping when the DEVICE isn't an interface described in
    /etc/shorewall/interfaces. This is in preparation for the upcoming
    change to the way that --physdev-out works in iptables/Netfilter;
    that change is now scheduled for kernel 2.6.20.

21) If your kernel and iptables have extended multiport support, then
    Shorewall will use that support for the destination port when
    generating rules from entries in the /etc/shorewall/tcrules file.

22) The 'safe-start' and 'safe-restart' command have been
    improved. Both now accept an optional directory name; if supplied,
    Shorewall will look first in that directory for configuration
    files.

    The commands have also been enhanced to only restore the
    configuration once in the event of a failure. Previously, if there
    was a current 'save' command in effect, then that configuration
    would be restored on a failure and then the last-running
    configuration would be restored.

23) The 'try' command has been reimplemented with new semantics. 

    If Shorewall is started then the firewall state is saved to a
    temporary saved configuration (/var/lib/shorewall/.try). Next, if
    Shorewall is currently started then a restart command is issued;
    otherwise, a start command is performed. if an error occurs during
    the  compliation phase  of  the  restart or start, the command
    terminates without changing the Shorewall state. If an error occurs
    during the restart phase, then a 'shorewall restore' is performed
    using the saved configuration. If an error occurs during the start
    phase, then Shorewall is  cleared. If the start/restart succeeds
    and a timeout is specified then a 'clear' or 'restore' is performed
    after timeout seconds. 

24) The syntax of the 'export' command has been made slightly
    friendlier.

    The old syntax:

	export <directory1> [user@]system:[<directory2>]

    It is now:

        export <directory1> [user@]system[:<directory2>]

    In other words, if you don't need to specify <directory2>, you may
    omit the colon (":") following the system name.
    
    The old syntax is still accepted -- that is, you can still 
    type:

        export firewall2:

    which is equivalent to

        export firewall2

25) Shorewall commands may be speeded up slightly by using a
    'capabilities' file. The 'capabilities' file was originally
    designed for use with Shorewall Lite and records the
    iptables/Netfilter features available on the target system.

    To generate a capabilities file, execute the following command as
    root:

      shorewall show -f capabilities > /etc/shorewall/capabilities

    When you install a new kernel and/or iptables, be sure to generate
    a new capabilities file.
	
26) When syslogd is run with the -C option (which in some
    implementations causes syslogd to log to an in-memory circular
    buffer), /sbin/shorewall will now use the 'logread' command to read
    the log from that buffer. This is for combatibility with OpenWRT.

27) There is now a ":T" qualifier in /etc/shorewall/tcrules which
    causes the resulting rule to be inserted into the POSTROUTING
    chain.

28) The program /usr/share/shorewall/wait4ifup can be used to wait for
    a network device (such as a ppp device) to reach the UP state. 
    
	/usr/share/shorewall/wait4ifup <interface> [ <seconds> ]

    The program will wait for up to <seconds> seconds for the 
    named <interface> to reach the UP state. If <seconds> is not given,
    60 seconds is assumed.

    The exit status is zero if <interface> comes up within <seconds>
    seconds and non-zero otherwise.

29) Previously, 'ipsecnat' tunnels allowed AH traffic by default
    (unless 'isecnat:noah' was given). Given that AH is incompatible
    with nat-traversal, 'ipsecnat' now implies 'ipsecnat:noah'.

30) Shorewall now generates half as many rules as previously in the
    'blacklst' chain when BLACKLIST_LOGLEVEL is specified.

31) Beginning with Shorewall 3.4.0, if EXPORTPARAMS=No in
    shorewall.conf then Shorewall will not process
    /etc/shorewall/params when the compiled script is run. With
    EXPORTPARAMS=No, any shell variables needed at run-time must be set
    in /etc/shorewall/init.

    In a Shorewall/Shorewall Lite environment, this allows
    /etc/shorewall/params to be written to run exclusively
    on the administrative system while /etc/shorewall/init runs
    exclusively on the firewall system.

    So shell variables required at compile time may be set in
    /etc/shorewall/params and those required at run-time may be set in
    /etc/shorewall/init.

    Note 1: If you need shell variables values in your
    /etc/shorewall/stop or /etc/shorewall/stopped script, then you need
    to set their values in /etc/shorewall/stop. /etc/shorewall/init is
    not invoked during processing of the 'stop' and 'clear' commands.

    Note 2: EXPORTPARAMS was actually introduced in Shorewall version
    3.2.9. It is described here for the benefit of those who did not
    install that version.

Problems Corrected in 3.4.1

1)  The "shorewall-[lite] [re]start and stop" commands reset the
    proxy_arp flag on all interfaces on the system making it impossible
    to control proxy arp manually with Shorewall installed. There was a
     partial fix included in 3.4.0; unfortunately, it did not correct the
    problem completely. Shorewall 3.4.1 includes the rest of the change 
    necessarey to only clear proxy arp if there were entries in
    /etc/shorewall/proxyarp the last time that Shorewall was
    [re]started.

2)  If the log-prefix in a log message exceeded 29 characters, 
    'shorewall restart' fails with 'truncate: command not found' and a
    possible segmentation fault in iptables.

3)  Log messages specifying a log tag had two spaces appended to the
    log prefix. This could cause mysterious "log-prefix truncated"
    messages. 

4)  When nested zones were defined in the /etc/shorewall/zones file and
    IMPLICIT_CONTINUE=Yes was given in /etc/shorewall/shorewall.conf,
    shell error messages ( usually '<zone>: not found' ) during
    compilation resulted.

5)  Use of CONTINUE policies lead to startup errors with a message
    such as the following:

       Applying Policies...
       iptables v1.3.7: Couldn't load target
       `CONTINUE':/usr/local/lib/iptables/libipt_CONTINUE.so: cannot open
       shared object file: No such file or directory

       Try `iptables -h' or 'iptables --help' for more information.
       
          ERROR: Command "/sbin/iptables -A net2c148 -j CONTINUE"
          Failed

6)  If there were hosts defined as 'critical' in
    /etc/shorewall/routestopped then problems occured in two cases:

    i) On a Shorewall Lite system when 'shorewall stop' or 'shorewall
    clear' was issued.

    ii) On Shorewall or Shorewall lite system when 'start' or 'restart'
    failed during execution of the compiled script and there was no saved
    configuration ('shorewall[-lite] save' has not been issued).

    The symptoms were that the following shell messages were issued and
    the 'critical' hosts were not enabled:

      /var/lib/shorewall/.start: line nnn: source_ip_range: command not found
      /var/lib/shorewall/.start: line nnm: dest_ip_range: command not found
    
Other changes in 3.4.1

1)  Several changes are included which allow testing of experimental
    versions of Shorewall on systems with 3.4.1 and later 3.4 releases
    installed. Among these changes is the detection and reporting of
    "Address Type Match" which may be used in future 3.4 releases.
    These changes have no effect on normal Shorewall operation.