# Description
The standard library's `path add` function has some surprising side
effects that I attempt to address in this PR:
1. Paths added, if they are symbolic links, should not be resolved to
their targets. Currently, resolution happens.
Imagine the following:
```nu
# Some time earlier, perhaps even not by the user, a symlink is created
mkdir real-dir
ln -s real-dir link-dir
# Then, step to now, with link-dir that we want in our PATHS variable
use std
path add link-dir
```
In the current implementation of `path add`, it is _not_ `link-dir` that
will be added, as has been stated in the command. It is instead
`real-dir`. This is surprising. Users have the agency to do this
resolution if they wish with `path expand` (sans a `--no-symlink` flag):
for example, `path add (link-dir | path expand)`
In particular, when I was trying to set up
[fnm](https://github.com/Schniz/fnm), a Node.js version manager, I was
bitten by this fact when `fnm` told me that an expected path had not
been added to the PATHS variable. It was looking for the non-resolved
link. The user in [this
comment](https://github.com/Schniz/fnm/issues/463#issuecomment-1710050737)
was likely affected by this too.
Shells, such as nushell, can handle path symlinks just fine. Binary
lookup is unaffected. Let resolution be opt-in.
Lastly, there is some convention already in place for **not** resolving
path symlinks in the [default $env.ENV_CONVERSIONS
table](57452337ff/crates/nu-utils/src/sample_config/default_env.nu (L65)
).
2. All existing paths in the path variable should be left untouched.
Currently, they are `path expand`-ed (including symbolic link
resolution).
Path add should mean just that: prepend/append this path.
Instead, it currently means that, _plus mutate all other paths in the
variable_.
Again, users have the agency to do this with something like `$env.PATH =
$env.PATH | split row (char esep) | path expand`.
3. Minorly, I update documentation on running tests in
`crates/nu-std/CONTRIBUTING.md`. The offered command to run the standard
library test suite was no longer functional. Thanks to @weirdan in [this
Discord
conversation](https://discord.com/channels/601130461678272522/614593951969574961/1256029201119576147)
for the context.
# User-Facing Changes
(Written from the perspective of release notes)
- The standard library's `path add` function no longer resolves symlinks
in either the newly added paths, nor the other paths already in the
variable.
# Tests + Formatting
A test for the changes working correctly has been added to
`crates/nu-std/tests/test_std.nu` under the test named
`path_add_expand`.
You can quickly verify this new test and the existing `path add` test
with the following command:
```nu
cargo run -- -c 'use crates/nu-std/testing.nu; NU_LOG_LEVEL=INFO testing run-tests --path crates/nu-std --test path_add'
```
All commands suggested in the issue template have been run and complete
without error.
# After Submitting
I'll add a release note to [the
documentation](https://github.com/nushell/nushell.github.io) after the
PR is merged.
11 KiB
Contributing
Welcome to the Nushell standard library and thank you for considering contributing!
Ideas for the standard library
If you've got a great idea, or just want to contribute to open source by working on the Nushell standard library, we invite you to talk to the team before you start coding. You'll find we're friendly, passionate about Nushell and always open to new ideas!
You'll generally find the team members on
Discord #standard-library
channel and can have
preliminary discussions there to clarify the issues involved.
You can open a GitHub issue to have a more focused discussion of your idea.
Generally, we think the standard library should contain items that are relevant
to most/all Nushell users regardless of the application space they're working
in. If your idea isn't quite so broadly applicable, consider publishing it in
nu_scripts
.
Preliminary discussions should focus on the user benefit your idea would provide.
How many users will be affected by your idea, how much would it help them solve a problem or work more productively? Given consensus on the user benefit, the team will be motivated to help you create, deploy and maintain a solution long term.
Lifecycle of a change
- Verify the team thinks your idea is potentially relevant and useful, as above.
- If it's more than a simple bug fix, open a placeholder PR as soon as you get
started and set it to draft status.
This will alert other contributors that you're working in this area and let you advertise roughly what scope of changes you're thinking of. See below for details. - Get things working in your local development environment.
If you have questions along the way, you can post a question in your PR or have a more casual discussion with Nushell fans on Discord#implementation-chat
channel. - When you get to an appropriate state of doneness, push your changes to the PR and remove the draft status.
- Team members and other contributors will then review your PR.
Respond to any review comments they raise and address them one way or another. (Not all comments demand you make a change!) - When you and the team are comfortable with the PR, a team member will merge it into the repo and you can delete your working branch.
- If you've added a whole new command or made a breaking change,
(strongly) consider writing it up for the release notes.
Currently, release notes are maintained in a different repo,nushell.github.io
. Make your change in a local clone of that repo and submit a PR to the release notes repo to get it integrated.
Developing
(All paths below shown relative to the root folder of the git repository containing the standard library.)
Setup
- Install the Rust toolchain and Nushell build tools.
See
nushell
'sCONTRIBUTING.md
for details. The standard library is tightly coupled to a particular version of Nushell interpreter, you need to be running that version to test your changes (unlike a "normal" script module library). - Clone the Nushell repo containing the standard library and create a feature
branch for your development work.
Currently, that's the Nushell interpreter source repo.
Once you set your working directory to the root of this repository, you'll generally leave it there throughout the session.git clone https://github.com/nushell/nushell cd nushell git checkout -b <featureBranch>
- In your IDE, open the folder within the repository containing the standard
library. The folder is currently
./crates/nu-std
, and it is a Rust crate, containing aCargo.toml
and subfolders:src/
(which contains the Rust code to load the standard library modules into memory for efficiency),lib
(which contains all the script module sources for the standard library),tests/
(unit tests for lib).
The PR
Assuming you've already validated the need with other Nushell contributors, you're focusing on design and implementation at this point. Share your thinking all along the way!
You can open a draft pull request based on a small, placeholder code change and use the PR comments to outline your design and user interface. You'll get feedback from other contributors that may lead to a more robust and perhaps more idomatic solution. The threads in the PR can be a convenient reference for you when writing release notes and for others on the team when researching issues.
Note
the PR will not get final code review or be merged until you remove the draft status.
Design considerations
The standard library consists of Nushell custom commands and their associated
environment variables, packaged in script modules underneath module std
. For
background on scripts, custom commands and modules, see the
Modules chapter of the Nushell book.
To add a completely new module, for example, a foo
command and some
foo subcommand
s, you will be dealing with 2 new source files: the module
source itself (./crates/nu-std/lib/foo.nu
) and a unit tests file
(./crates/nu-std/tests/test_foo
); and will be modifying 1 or 2 existing files
(./crates/nu-std/lib/mod.nu
and possibly ./crates/nu-std/src/lib.rs
). This
is described below:
-
Source for a custom command
foo
should go in./crates/nu-std/lib/foo.nu
.- A source file will typically implement multiple subcommands and possibly
a main command as well.
Useexport def
to make these names public to your users. - If your command is updating environment variables, you must use
export def --env
(instead ofexport def
) to define the subcommand,export-env {}
to initialize the environment variables and$env.VAR = val
to update them. For an example of a custom command which modifies environment variables, see:./crates/nu-std/lib/dirs.nu
.
For an example of a custom command which does not modify environment variables, see:./crates/nu-std/lib/assert.nu
. - If your standard library module wishes to use a utility from another
module of the standard library, for example
log info
, you need to import it directly from its module in theuse
statement.
This is... your foo.nu ... export def mycommand [] { use log "log info" . . . log info "info level log message" . . . }
use log "log info"
rather thanuse std "log info"
(which is the usual way commands are imported from the standard library) because yourfoo
module is also a child module understd
.
- A source file will typically implement multiple subcommands and possibly
a main command as well.
-
Unit tests for
foo
should go in./crates/nu-std/tests/test_foo.nu
. Thou shalt provide unit tests to cover your changes.- Unit tests should use one of the
assert
commands to check a condition and report the failure in a standard format. - To import
assert
commands for use in your test, import them viause std
(unlike theuse log
for your source code; the tests are not modules understd
). For example:
The choice of import style is up to you.... your test_foo.nu ... def test1 [] { use std . . . std assert greater $l $r . . . std assert $predicate } def test2 [] { use std ['assert greater' assert] . . . assert greater $l $r . . . assert $predicate }
- Unit tests should use one of the
-
A
foo
command will be exposed to the user asstd foo
(at a minimum).
To enable this, update file./crates/nu-std/lib/mod.nu
and add this code:export use foo * # command doesn't update environment export-env { use bar * # command *does* update environment }
The
use *
hoists the public definitions infoo.nu
intomod.nu
and thus into thestd
namespace. -
Some commands from the standard library are also preloaded, so user can invoke them without explicit import via
use std ...
.
A command implemented asstd foo
, can be preloaded as a barefoo
:- modify
./crates/nu-std/src/lib.rs
, - find the initialization of the "prelude" at line 90 or thereabouts
- add
("foo", "foo")
- or, to be preloaded as
std foo
, add("std foo", "foo")
.
(This code may be restructured soon: if you can't find it, check with the team on Discord.)
Note
that you will need to recompile the Nushell interpreter to test this change, see the "setup" section of Nushell'sCONTRIBUTING.md
. - modify
More design guidelines:
- Ensure your custom command provides useful help.
This is done with comments before thedef
for the custom command. - Use
error make
to report can't-proceed errors to user, notlog error
. - Use
log info
to provide verbose progress messages that the user can optionally enable for troubleshooting. e.g:NU_LOG_LEVEL=INFO foo # verbose messages from command foo
- Use
assert
in unit tests to check for and report failures.
Useful Commands
- Run all unit tests for the standard library:
cargo run -- -c 'use crates/nu-std/testing.nu; testing run-tests --path crates/nu-std'
Note
this uses the debug version of NU interpreter from the same repo, which is the usual development scenario.
Log level 'ERROR' shows only failures (meaning no output is the desired outcome).
Log level 'INFO' shows progress by module and 'DEBUG' show each individual test. - Run all tests for a specific test module, e.g,
crates/nu-std/tests/test_foo.nu
cargo run -- -c 'use crates/nu-std/testing.nu; testing run-tests --path crates/nu-std --module test_foo'
- Run a custom command with additional logging (assuming you have instrumented
the command with
log <level>
, as we recommend.)NU_LOG_LEVEL=INFO std foo bar bas # verbose NU_LOG_LEVEL=DEBUG std foo bar bas # very verbose
- Build and run Nushell (e.g, if you modify the prelude):
cargo run
Git commit and repo conventions
The standard library project uses the same protocols and conventions
for squashing git commits and handling github PRs as the core Nushell project.
Please see the "Git etiquette" section of
Nushell's CONTRIBUTING.md
for details.